Selecting the appropriate kind of underfloor heating system is essential for effectively heating and insulating your house. Electric film systems and electric cable systems are two common choices that are frequently taken into account. Making the right decision between them is crucial to obtaining the best balance between comfort and energy efficiency because each has pros and cons of its own.
Heating cables are a component of electric cable systems, which are buried beneath the floor. When electricity flows through these cables, heat is produced, warming the floor and then radiating upward. Because of their adaptability and ability to be installed in different floor types, cable systems are appropriate for both new construction and renovations. They are frequently used to provide a steady and manageable heat source in kitchens, bathrooms, and living rooms.
Conversely, electric film systems make use of incredibly thin heating components that are usually put directly beneath engineered wood or laminate flooring. Because of their low thermal mass, these systems heat up quickly and respond quickly to changes in room temperature. Because of their reputation for being simple to install, electric film systems can be a smart option for retrofitting existing spaces where floor height is an issue.
A number of factors should be taken into account when choosing between cable and film systems in order to determine which option best meets your needs. The efficiency and distribution of heat across the floor surface are important factors to take into account. Because of their uniformly spaced heating elements, cable systems distribute heat more evenly throughout the space. In the long run, this may lead to a constant temperature profile and decreased operating expenses.
The cost and complexity of installation should also be considered. Installing cable systems is frequently more labor-intensive, especially in thicker floor types like concrete. Because they are thin and flexible, electric film systems can be installed more quickly and easily, which can result in lower installation costs—especially for larger areas.
The decision between film systems and electric cable ultimately comes down to your unique needs and the features of your house. These choices provide efficient underfloor heating options that can improve your living spaces’ comfort and energy efficiency. You can choose a system that fits both your budget and your heating requirements by being aware of the differences between these models and taking your priorities into account.
| Aspect | Comparison |
| Installation | Cable: More complex, requires embedding in a layer of screed. Film: Easier, lays directly under flooring. |
| Cost | Cable: Generally more expensive due to installation complexity. Film: Typically more affordable. |
| Heating Efficiency | Cable: Offers more uniform heating across the floor. Film: Heats up faster but may have less uniform distribution. |
| Thickness | Cable: Requires thicker flooring. Film: Thin profile, minimal impact on floor height. |
What is the difference between infrared warm floor and cable?
The fundamental distinction lies in the concept of labor. Heating systems use various methods to transform electricity into thermal energy, even though electricity is still the primary source of heating.
IK – Paul
In order to heat the space, infrared radiation is created by converting electricity. Rods are sealed into the ultra-thin film that makes up floors.
Infrared radiation is released by the heating elements as the electricity is transferred. The objects in the vicinity have heated surfaces. Natural air circulation removes extra heat from the surface.
The movie offers the following benefits:
-
Fast warming up – immediately after turning on the apartment, pleasant heat is poured. Under the influence of IR rays, a person begins to feel a rush of heat, tactilely feels a temperature of approximately 10 ° C more than is actually.
Cable floor
When determining which type of warm floor is preferable—cable or infrared—you should carefully examine the theory behind heating using a heating wire.
A cable with one or two conductive veins made of a material with a high specific resistance is used to heat the space. The cores warm up when an electric current is passed through them, transferring the heat from the outer shell. The floor’s surface and the installed flooring are thus heated.
The following benefits come from using the heating cable:
-
Laying is carried out in a layer of screed or tile glue that plays the function of a kind of radiator. As a result, uniform heating of the room is ensured, the absence of cold zones.
The primary distinction between the warm floor’s cable and infrared technology is how the room is heated differently. The surface of objects is heated by infrared radiation. Air is warmed by cable-heated floors.
When deciding between a cable or film warm floor system for your home, it"s important to consider several key factors. Cable systems, such as electric heating cables installed within the floor, offer precise heating control and are suitable for various floor types. They are effective in heating larger spaces and can be installed in specific areas. On the other hand, film systems consist of ultra-thin heating elements placed directly under the floor finish. They are easier to install, especially in renovations, due to their low-profile nature. Film systems provide uniform heating across the floor surface and are energy-efficient. The choice between cable and film warm floors depends on your specific needs: if you prioritize precise control and flexibility, cable systems might be ideal; whereas, if easy installation and energy efficiency are key, then film systems could be the better choice. Ultimately, both options offer effective heating solutions; the decision should be based on factors like installation convenience, energy efficiency, and the desired heating performance for your home.
Which warm floor is more economical, ik or cable?
When evaluating the effectiveness of electric and infrared warm floors, it is important to consider the precise application of the heating system. When using infrared heating alone to heat the room, the amount of electricity used will be more than or roughly half that of an electric wire.
One drawback of infrared heating is that the room cools down nearly instantly when the power is turned off. Since the cable is buried under a layer of screed, the heat buildup in the screed keeps the cable warm for a while even after the electricity is turned off. As a result, the cable is far more cost-effective than the movie, particularly when considering the usage of thermostats.
Which floor heating is more reliable, cable or IR?
When it comes to dependability, infrared systems outperform wires since they are stronger and more resistant to mechanical harm. Only one section of film emerges from the system if the heating element is damaged. System performance is totally lost when there is damage to the cables.
When deciding between an electric warm floor and an infrared warm floor, you should also consider operational safety. Cable systems, particularly those composed of two-core wires, prevail in this situation. Because of the shielding layer on the cable, an electric shock cannot occur.
Both cable and film warm floor systems have advantages and disadvantages that should be taken into account when choosing one for your house. Direct heat is provided by heating cables that are buried under the flooring in cable systems. They are a good option for renovations because they are adaptable and can be installed in different types of floors. Conversely, film systems make use of incredibly thin heating components that are hidden beneath an engineered wood or laminate layer. They have quick heat-up times and are simple to install.
Ease of installation is an important consideration. When it comes to installation, film systems are typically easier than cable systems. Film systems are more do-it-yourself friendly because they come in rolls that are simple to cut to the exact size of the room. For even heat distribution, cable systems need to be carefully planned for, and in larger spaces, professional installation may be more appropriate.
Energy economy and reaction time are additional factors. Because of the way they are designed, film systems usually heat up faster, which makes them perfect for spaces where rapid heating is required. While cable systems react a little more slowly, they can hold heat for a longer period of time after being turned off, which could result in long-term energy cost savings.
Both cable and film systems have the potential to be dependable in the long run provided they are installed and maintained correctly. Because of their durability, cable systems may be simpler to fix if just a small portion is broken. Despite their general durability, film systems may need extra caution during installation to protect the fragile heating components.
In conclusion, your unique requirements and tastes will determine whether you choose a cable or film warm floor system. If you value speedy heat-up times and simplicity of installation, a film system might be a better choice. On the other hand, a cable system might be the best option if you value adaptability, long-term durability, and possibly lower energy costs. In the end, both systems can offer your house effective and cozy heating options, improving overall comfort during the winter.
