What is the difference between an expansion tank and a hydroaccumulator?

It can be difficult to comprehend the inner workings of the insulation and heating systems in your house, particularly when it comes to parts like hydroaccumulators and expansion tanks. These two appliances have different functions, but they are both vital to preserving the effectiveness and security of your heating system. What precisely makes them unique, then?

Let’s start by discussing how an expansion tank works. Water expands when it heats up in a heating system, which can cause a pressure buildup that is dangerous. An expansion tank is utilized in order to guard against harm to the system and guarantee its longevity. In essence, it serves as a cushion, absorbing extra water volume and pressure changes to keep the system’s operating pressure steady and secure.

However, a hydroaccumulator—also known as a pressure tank or vessel—performs a slightly different function. Its main purpose is to ensure that water flows through the system steadily and consistently, though it also assists in controlling water pressure. Ensuring a dependable water supply for diverse household requirements is especially crucial in regions with irregular water supply or varying demand.

What distinguishes these two devices, then? Their principal roles in the heating system hold the key. Although both expansion tanks and hydroaccumulators handle water pressure, the former is more concerned with controlling pressure and safeguarding against high pressure, while the latter places more importance on preserving a constant water supply. It’s critical to comprehend the differences between these parts to guarantee the safe and effective operation of the heating system in your house.

Design and function of an expansion tank

I’d like to go over the components of this device’s design in order to help you better understand how the heating system unit works. These components include:

1. Connection pipe.
2. diaphragm.
3. Working cavity.
4. Gas tank.
5. Air nipple.

The device operates on a very basic principle: it compensates for the coolant’s expansion caused by the free space, which is kept apart by a unique soft rubber device.

The laws of physics dictate that when heating any liquid in the distribution, the maximum permissible pressure value must increase. Without this tank, the hot water system that supplies the radiators could be vulnerable to a variety of malfunctions.

As a better way to illustrate the key points, I usually provide an example. To put it another way, when water is heated to 100 degrees, its volume increases by 4.3%.

A 1 degree increase in temperature without accounting for pipeline deformation can result in a 3 bar increase in pressure, which, in the event of major changes, would be disastrous for the boiler as well as the radiators.

Over time, all connections will inevitably depressurize, causing the liquid to form a flood. This is an unpleasant phenomenon that will require forced flooring repair in any home.

Device and purpose of the hydro accumulator

These devices have unique structural characteristics, of which I can also provide a list. The apparatus consists of:

1. Air nipple.
2. Diaphragm.
3. Metal housing.
4. Gas cavity.
5. Working tank.
6. Hole for connection of liquid supply.

The majority of owners believe that the unit’s blue housing indicates that it functions to collect water, but it does more than just that.

I would like to draw attention to the frequent head fluctuations in the water supply system. Hydro-impacts can happen when a powerful pump is operating, and all of these excesses effectively dampen the device, preventing leaks in the pipeline, fittings, and taps.

Since the pump will be turned off more frequently with such a device, I have always reassured users that it will last much longer. Despite having a straightforward construction, the hydraulic accumulator’s operation helps you avoid a lot of issues.

A unique membrane was created inside the apparatus because, since the tank is filled with drinking water, there will be unsightly rust and other chemical deposits from the water’s contact with the metal body.

Compared to the heating expansion tank, which is composed of the most durable material, this element is more prone to deformation.

What are the differences

The hydroaccumulator keeps the system safe from hydrostorms by accumulating the required amount of water. The heat exchanger’s expansion tank guards against thermal expansion.

To help you understand the operational differences, I will now give a brief description of each appliance’s operating procedures.

How an expansion tank works

The red-colored tanks that people are accustomed to seeing are made to remove any harmful effects that result from heating the coolant and raising the system pressure. Since the boiler operates on a closed wiring system and cannot function without such equipment, excess liquid is forced out of the system and into a reservoir that is specifically designated for that purpose in the expansion tank.

Any coolant that has been heated will eventually become excess. To give you an example, the coefficient of expansion of regular water is 0.3% for every 10 degrees that it is heated. Because of its high density, liquid lacks any unique compression characteristics when compared to gas.

Breaking the system is the only way out, and that is something that shouldn’t be permitted. Experts have created a somewhat useful and secure gadget to prevent these uncomfortable circumstances, but it requires modification to function properly.

How a hydro accumulator works

In contrast to the tank, the hydroaccumulator is a vital component of the water supply system and operates directly within it. The two types of equipment have the same goal, but they operate in slightly different ways.

With a diaphragm shaped like a pear, this kind of unit will fill up until the remaining air pressure is nearly equal. Since the liquid must continue to be suitable for use, the element itself is made of food-grade rubber, and because of its unique shape, the water does not come into contact with the metal.

There is a diaphragm in the expansion tank as well, but it is placed slightly differently and separates the tank into two sections. The heat transfer medium is inside one of them, while air or gas is inside the other.

Because it is composed of high-quality rubber, this element can tolerate temperatures as high as 90 degrees Celsius when needed.

I see similarities between the two types of products in terms of ensuring the user has the appropriate amount of water, as well as safeguarding against overpressure and hydrostroke.

After all, you can’t escape this instant every time the pump is abruptly turned on and off. It is anticipated that the hydroaccumulator will supply liquid to the taps for a while without experiencing a drop in head. This will considerably ease the pump’s workload and increase the pump’s lifespan.

Anyone trying to maximize their insulation and heating system must know the distinction between a hydroaccumulator and an expansion tank. Although they both have vital roles to play, they differ in their roles and traits.

First of all, closed-loop heating systems—like those seen in many homes—are the main applications for expansion tanks. Its primary function is to allow water to expand as it warms up, avoiding pressure buildup that can harm the system. In comparison to hydroaccumulators, expansion tanks are usually smaller and placed closer to the boiler or water heater.

In contrast, the purpose of a hydroaccumulator—also referred to as a pressure tank or vessel—is to keep the water pressure in a home supply system constant. By storing water under pressure, it lowers the frequency of pump operation and enables constant flow rates. Hydroaccumulators are frequently utilized in systems where low municipal water pressure or well-water homes pose a risk for fluctuations in water pressure.

Their roles within the system are one of the main distinctions between the two. A hydroaccumulator is designed to stabilize water pressure in water supply systems, whereas an expansion tank is intended to accommodate thermal expansion in heating systems. It’s crucial to comprehend this distinction in order to choose the ideal component for your unique requirements.

Hydroaccumulators and expansion tanks have different installation and sizing requirements. The amount of water in the heating system and the anticipated temperature rise during operation are taken into account when sizing expansion tanks. In contrast, the desired water pressure range and the system’s flow rate are taken into account when sizing hydroaccumulators.

In summary, expansion tanks and hydroaccumulators have different functions, but both are essential to preserving the effectiveness and functionality of water supply and heating systems. Homeowners can ensure optimal performance and longevity when designing or upgrading their systems by making informed decisions based on their understanding of the differences between these components and their respective functions.

In the world of home heating and insulation, understanding the difference between an expansion tank and a hydroaccumulator is crucial. While both serve important roles in a household"s water system, they function differently. An expansion tank is primarily designed to deal with thermal expansion in a closed-loop water heating system, preventing pressure buildup and potential damage to pipes and fixtures. On the other hand, a hydroaccumulator, also known as a pressure tank, helps maintain consistent water pressure in a household"s water supply system by storing pressurized water. Essentially, the expansion tank focuses on managing temperature-related issues, while the hydroaccumulator ensures steady water pressure throughout the home. Understanding these distinctions can aid homeowners in effectively maintaining their water systems and ensuring optimal performance.

Video on the topic

Hydro-bank without a membrane or eternal hydroaccumulator

Connection of the expansion tank or accumulator using Valtec VT special fittings.538.N

Expansion tanks or accumulators

Accumulator and expansion tank. Their purpose, difference and adjustment.