Water or antifreeze in the heating system

For your home heating system, selecting between water and antifreeze can have a big impact on longevity and performance. Before selecting, it is important to be aware of the differences between each option as each has pros and cons that need to be taken into account.

Water is frequently used in heating systems because it is a common and affordable option. It is easy to install and maintain initially because it is widely available and efficient at transferring heat. However, the fact that water freezes easily in cold climates is a significant disadvantage of using it alone. If appropriate safety measures are not followed, this could cause major harm to the system.

Conversely, antifreeze, which is usually combined with water to form a solution, provides freezing protection and is therefore the recommended choice in colder climates. In order to keep radiators and pipes from bursting in below-freezing temperatures, antifreeze solutions include additives that lower the freezing point of water. Antifreeze solutions are more expensive than regular water and may need more involved maintenance procedures, so this extra protection has a price.

Climate is a big factor when choosing between water and antifreeze for your heating system. Water might be a more sensible and economical option in warmer climates where freezing is not an issue. However, the extra defense offered by antifreeze can help avoid expensive repairs and downtime in colder regions where freezing temperatures are typical.

It’s also critical to take the environment into account when making decisions. Water is an eco-friendly and natural solution, but some antifreeze solutions contain chemicals that can be dangerous if not disposed of correctly. This worry can be lessened by selecting an environmentally friendly or biodegradable antifreeze.

In conclusion, choosing between water and antifreeze for your heating system is an important choice that has to be carefully thought out in light of various factors like cost, environmental impact, and climate. You can minimize risks and ensure efficient and dependable home heating by making an informed decision by being aware of the benefits and drawbacks of each option.

Search for our blog

Choosing water or antifreeze for your heating system is a crucial choice when it comes to heating your house. Each choice has advantages and disadvantages. Water is a popular option because it transfers heat well and is inexpensive. Nevertheless, in extremely cold weather, it may freeze and harm the system. Conversely, antifreeze offers superior temperature control and keeps things from freezing, but it can be more expensive and may need more frequent maintenance. In the end, the choice is based on individual preferences, financial constraints, and environmental conditions. Making the right decision for their heating needs can be facilitated for homeowners by being aware of the distinctions between water and antifreeze.

Our group VKontakte

Latest articles on the blog

Boiler (water heater) for aerated concrete. How to fix it and is it possible

There are many homes now, both private and multi-apartment.

How to install water meters. In an apartment or private house.

Water for private homes and apartments is becoming more and more expensive. If you choose to pay with…

How to remove (replace) one cracked tile from the wall or floor. Not

It occurs, particularly in newly constructed homes, that one tile is all that is on the wall or…

Smart socket. Management via WiFi, bought with AliExpress

In this century of computerization, components of the smart home are now available to us.

Canyon Led LED lamps (GU 5.3). My detailed review

I’m still fixing up my apartment (I spent a little time there in 2015).

Ask a question or write a letter

What to choose: water or antifreeze for heating systems

Homeowners frequently ask this query. However, antifreeze for heating systems is now used far less frequently in private homes than water. This is due to a few factors, the first of which is the diverse physicochemical characteristics of these coolants. As a result, the antifreeze heating system and the water heat system should have different designs.

Comparative characteristics of water and antifreeze

Water has several obvious benefits when used as a coolant, including accessibility, high specific heat, and affordability (though it isn’t free because the system shouldn’t be filled with tap water; instead, it should be distilled or treated properly). The primary drawback is that at zero degrees, the water expands and tears the heating system’s components. Antifreezes can freeze as low as -70 degrees Celsius. They do, however, possess a few disagreeable traits.

1. Their specific heat capacity is 10-15% lower than that of the water: they heat up slower and give the heat worse, so you need a more powerful boiler.
2. They are denser (10-20%) and more viscous (30-50%) than water. Therefore, a powerful pump for the circulation of the coolant, large diameter pipes and more powerful heating radiators for antifreeze will be required.
3. When heated, they expand 30-40% more than water. So, you need 2 times larger in volume a closed expansion tank.
4. Non -freezing do not have surface tension and 50% more fluid than water. With the smallest flaws in the sealing of joints, the antifreeze begins to leak, especially when cooling the system, when the diameters of the pipeline elements decrease. Therefore, the heat system should have a minimum possible number of joints, and they should be at any time available for verification and repair.

Features of well-known coolants

As a result, using non-freezing liquids with a heating system designed for use under water is not appropriate. If antifreeze is to be used for home heating, a more advanced and expensive system must be designed beforehand.

Properties and features of the use of antifreeze in heating systems

Two types of non-frozen private heat systems are available for purchase: aqueous solutions of ethylene and propylene glycol. Unlike water, glycols enter a hard phase gradually as the temperature drops; the range is 10–15 °C from the point at which crystallization begins to full solidification. Within this range, the liquid does not expand in volume but instead thickens and gels into a "fur coat." Two "formats" in which glycols are sold are:

1. Concentrate with a crystallization start temperature -65 ° C. It is assumed that the buyer himself will dilute it with softened water to the necessary parameters. In the form of concentrate, only ethylene glycol of antifreezes are sold.
2. Ready -made solutions with freezing temperature -30 ° C.

In order to preserve the concentrate and achieve a freezing temperature of -20 or -15 °C, the homeowner can still dilute it. Diluting non-freezing by more than 50% will lessen its protective qualities.

Additives and accessors are a part of every non-freezing liquid’s composition. Their objective:

• protection of the metal elements of the system from corrosion;
• dissolution of scale and precipitation;
• protection against destruction of rubber seals;
• Foaming protection.

There is no standard formula for antifreeze; instead, every brand has its own combination of additives. As such, you should educate yourself about the different types of additives and their purposes before selecting non-freezing.

The house’s heating system’s antifreeze is highly prone to overheating; if the temperature rises above a certain point (which varies depending on the brand), the additives and ethylene glycol break down, producing solid precipitation and acids. Nar develops on the boilers’ heating elements, the sealing components are destroyed, and severe corrosion starts. Foam formation starts when additives overheat and are destroyed, which causes the system to be dumped. Because of these factors, heating boiler manufacturers strongly advise against using antifreeze, especially ethylene glycol, in the system.

It is also impossible to use galvanized pipes: non -freezing corrodes zinc coating, white flakes are formed – insoluble sediment.

Antifreeze-induced damage to a gas boiler’s burner

An expansion tank is used to add antifreeze to the heating system. The coolant needs to be changed every four to five years.

Ethylene glycol antifreeze

Antifreezes with ethylene glycol are more widely used because of their relative affordability. Even in diluted form, ethylene glycol is extremely toxic, so the use of non-freezing fluids based on it is strictly prohibited in double-circuit systems where ethylene glycol can fall into water for hot water, as well as in open heating systems where the poison evaporates from the expansion tank to the surrounding space.

Crucial! Since non-freezing on ethylene glycol is colored red, it is simple to locate them in the DHW system.

Propylene glycol antifreeze

This generation of antifreeze is more costly and new. Food propilene glycol is even used in confectionery products under the name E1520 food supplement, but they are completely safe. Propylene glycol does not freeze and is therefore less damaging to metal and sealing components. It is advised to use them in double-circuit systems due to their safety.

Crucial! The antifreeze made of propylene glycol is green.

Red and green liquids that don’t freeze

Is it possible to pour antifers in the heating system

An automobile’s antifreeze The production of antifreeze is based on ethylene glycol; heating systems are not meant to use it. Its additives damage the heating system’s components because they are made for the operating conditions of car engines.

Because of the possibility of extended power outages, heating systems must be converted from using water to antifreeze. This is especially important for areas that are isolated from major cities. The alternative is to use solid fuel boilers (which run on firewood, coal, or pellets) and have backup power sources in the house. However, in order to avoid damaging pricey equipment, it is preferable to entrust the design and installation of such a system if the switch to non-freezing is unavoidable.

Video: how to choose antifreeze for heating

Did I enjoy the article? Distribute this to your friends:

Heating for heating systems, which is better: water or antifreeze

Water heating remains the primary method of heating buildings, even with all the technological advancements that use heated air, infrared radiation, or electric heaters for heating purposes. These systems are more affordable to install and operate than most alternatives, and they are dependable and efficient. Although water is implied to be used as a coolant by the term "water heating," its properties aren’t always ideal and are only appropriate in certain situations. The market offers a wide range of liquids for heating systems, making it possible to select the coolant with the best qualities for each unique situation.

Every coolant has a variety of benefits and drawbacks.

Requirements for the coolant

The liquid substance known as coolant serves to transfer thermal energy from the heat source to radiators for heating. The following list of qualities describes a good coolant for the heating system, depending on the application and operating conditions:

• High heat capacity (the ability to accumulate and preserve a certain amount of heat).
• A wide range of operating temperatures at which the liquid does not freeze and does not boil.
• Viscosity and density do not interfere with free circulation of liquid through the pipeline and the operation of pumping equipment.
• Chemically neutral. Contact with liquid does not lead to the destruction of gaskets and seals.
• Does not have corrosion effects on pipes, locking reinforcement, boiler equipment, heating devices and other equipment.
• The impurities contained do not settle on the walls of the pipes and do not lead to clogging the heat exchanger of the boiler.
• The physical and chemical properties of the fluid are stable and do not change under the influence of temperature or over time.
• Meets the requirements of fire safety and explosion safety, does not secrete toxic substances.

It is important to note that there does not currently exist a universal fluid that would be ideal for all heating types and simultaneously satisfy all requirements. The material of the boiler’s heat exchanger and pipeline, the mode of operation for temperature, the climate zone, and other factors must all be considered when selecting a heating fluid.

Rough estimates indicate that 70% of heating systems typically use water as a coolant. Such widespread appeal is not surprising and can be attributed to several factors:

1. Availability. Such fluid for heating systems is available in any area, at any time and at the same time free. At any time it can be added or replaced.
2. The specific heat capacity of the water is 4.187 J/(kg*k), and the density is 977 g/dm³. Such characteristics provide the highest heat transfer compared to other technical fluids.
3. Environmental Safety. In the case of leaks, pipe breakthroughs, as well as when replacing or valve, it does not pose the slightest danger to human health and does not require special conditions for work.
4. The design and materials of the devices are originally designed to work with water.

Prepared water works better for heating. with few salts and contaminants. You can process the water with bastling lime to remove calcium and magnesium salt and magnesium, and boiling will remove light salts and carbon dioxide. The water undergoes filtering after processing. Distilled water has already undergone a thorough purification process.

However, the drawbacks that restrict its use are innate to the water:

• Freezing temperature is 0 ° C. In the event of an accident and the absence of other heat sources to maintain temperature in the building, the water freezes. Expansion and transition to an ice state bringing into complete unusable pipelines, radiators, boilers and other equipment.
• Leads to corrosion of metal elements.
• The water that has not passed the preparation contains impurities, which over time are deposited in the form of sediment on the walls of the pipes, narrowing the passage, and clog the heat exchanger of the boiler, reducing its heat transfer.

The most popular coolant is water.

Presently available on the market is water that has already been treated for use in heating systems. This type of heating coolant has anti-corrosion qualities and keeps deposits from building up on the heat exchanger’s and pipes’ inner surfaces.

The term "antifreeze" refers to a group of liquids whose properties enable their use in heating systems and whose freezing point is lower than that of water. The antifreeze used in country homes’ heating systems has a freezing temperature range of -30 to -70 degrees Celsius and satisfies safety regulations.

Using ethyl alcohol, antifreeze, or other compounds is strictly prohibited. You should also avoid trying to make a coolant for the heating system by hand rather than using a specially prepared liquid. This is risky and can cause pipeline and equipment failure!

Selecting a heating liquid with the right characteristics is easy because there is a wide range of these compositions available on the market:

1. Ethylene glycol. The most common non -freezing fluid for heating. Some brands do not lose their properties at -70 ° C. At the same time, ethylene glycol gives a mixture of increased viscosity and the pump is required to serve it, the expansion coefficient requires the installation of an expansion tank, and toxicity – compliance with safety measures during maintenance or validity. Based on ethylene glycol, a popular heating fluid is produced warm house (TD-65).
2. Propylene glycol. Differs from ethylene glycol with safety and high heat transfer.
3. On a glycerin basis. Harmless to human health, durable antifreeze for heating. It has anti -corrosion properties.

You should carefully review the manufacturer’s recommendations before selecting a coolant for electrode heating boilers. Specific standards for the coolant’s electrical conductivity and resistance are also imposed during the boiler’s ionization process. Furthermore, the non-freezing fluid for heating systems that is acceptable for use is mentioned in a separate paragraph regarding the warranty obligations of boiler equipment manufacturers. In the event that this requirement is not met, warranty obligations are immediately terminated.

The decision you make regarding water or antifreeze for your heating system can have a big effect on how long and how efficiently your setup works. Both choices have benefits and cons, so it’s important to carefully consider each one.

Because it is readily available and reasonably priced, water is frequently used in heating systems. Since it is a natural heat conductor, warmth can be effectively distributed throughout your house. Furthermore, water is relatively easy to dispose of if necessary and presents little environmental risk. The freezing point of water must be taken into account, though, particularly in colder regions where frozen pipes may result in expensive repairs or even water damage.

However, at lower temperatures, antifreeze—typically a blend of water and glycol—provides protection against freezing. This can be especially helpful for homeowners in areas where severe winters are common. Additionally, antifreeze prolongs the life of the heating system and lowers maintenance needs by preventing corrosion inside the system. But antifreeze can be more expensive than water, and because of environmental concerns, disposing of it properly requires handling.

It’s important to take your climate, budget, and the impact on the environment into account when choosing between water and antifreeze for your heating system. Water might be a better choice if you live in a place with mild winters and want to keep expenses as low as possible. However, buying antifreeze might be a better idea if freezing temperatures are a concern or if you value the longevity and efficiency of your system.

The choice between water and antifreeze ultimately comes down to your priorities and unique situation. Speaking with a qualified heating technician can help you make an informed decision that will optimize the longevity and performance of your heating system. They can also offer insightful advice specific to your needs.

Video on the topic

Water or antifreeze in the heating system?

Heating coolant in the heating system. Change antifreeze to water

Water or antifreeze in the heating system?