Warm floor or battery, which is better in a private house?

Selecting the ideal heating system for your home is an important choice that will affect both your comfort level and energy efficiency. Warm floors and conventional radiators are two of the most well-liked options available. Every option has advantages and disadvantages, so choosing between them comes down to personal taste, financial constraints, and the particular requirements of your house.

Radiant floor heating, commonly referred to as warm floors, is an opulent and effective way to heat your house. With this system, heating elements are placed beneath the floor and radiate heat upward, warming the space from the bottom up. Warm floors ensure that the space is consistently warm, preventing cold spots and drafts through their even distribution of heat. Furthermore, radiant floor heating runs noiselessly—it doesn’t make the same noise as radiators or forced-air systems.

Conversely, conventional radiators have been a mainstay of residential heating systems for a very long time. These gadgets heat metal panels with steam or hot water, which transfers heat to the air around them. When heat is needed, radiators are renowned for their rapid response time and nearly instantaneous warmth. They can be seamlessly incorporated into both newly constructed and pre-existing homes with minimal disturbance, and their installation is comparatively simple.

There are a few things to consider when choosing between heated floors and radiators for your home. The cost is an important factor to take into account because there can be significant differences between the two systems’ initial installation costs and ongoing operating costs. Your choice will also be influenced by your home’s layout and design, as well as your own aesthetic and comfort preferences.

In conclusion, your priorities and situation will ultimately determine whether you choose radiators or heated floors. Warm floors are incredibly comfortable and energy-efficient, but traditional radiators heat up quickly and consistently for a potentially cheaper price. You can choose the heating system that best fits your private home by carefully weighing your options and taking into account your particular needs.

Types of warm floors

Water and electric floors are the two types of warm floors.

1. Water – consist of flexible pipes, along which the coolant heated to 30 – 35 degrees moves. The laying scheme of the highway is a "snake" or "snail". More often mounted under a cement concrete screed. Although, in the presence of wooden ceilings, styling is possible without filling concrete.

• Electric warm floors are:
• cable is a wire that can be located under any surface laid in a screed or between the heater bosses;
• mats – is also a cable type of structure, only the wire is already fixed on the substrate (mat) with a certain step;
• Infrared are a film with mounted carbon plates, the screed is not required, the laying process is simple and fast.

Types of radiators

When it comes to radiators, there are three different kinds made:

1. Aluminum radiators are the most common model. The entire battery body is made of aluminum, which makes it light and increases the level of heat transfer. The only negative is not high strength.
2. Bimetallic heating radiators – have an aluminum case with a steel or copper core. The presence of such an insert gives the product strength, it can withstand high pressure and temperature differences.
3. Cast iron batteries are classics, they are popular today, although they have an impressive weight and are quite inert. Have a long time heating for a long time, but they hold well and give heat well.

Radiators are further separated into forced and gravity types. After being heated in the boiler, the gravity system’s essence rises up the riser and falls when it cools, in accordance with the laws of physics.

One and two -pipes are present. It is assumed that batteries with forced action have a pump, which aids in promoting fluid in the pipes.

Paul"s pros and cons of

You should become familiar with the positives and negatives of each heating system as they are designed for particular environments in which they will perform best.

Installation

Every repair job is inconvenient and severely "beats" the pocketbook.

In most situations, a screed is needed if the "warm floor" water system is installed in a private residence. Doing it while the building is still being constructed is both more practical and superior. In order to set up this kind of sex in a newly renovated room, you will have to take the floor apart.

Subsequently, the installation of the warmest structure can begin, comprising a layer of thermal and hydraulic insulation, heating components, and concrete screed.

It takes a long time for a concrete layer to solidify—roughly 28 days—before you can apply the finish coating and operate the equipment.

The heated area and the components used in the "warm floor" system determine how much it will cost to install and operate. It’s crucial to calculate the number of contours and styling step correctly.

The surface will overheat if the pipes are positioned too frequently; therefore, you must lower the coolant’s heating temperature.

But since the cost of the material is rising, this is not financially advantageous. Furthermore, the floor’s effectiveness is diminished by its overly lengthy outline.

Economic operation

When heating floors, the air warms up two meters away from the flooring, resulting in uniform surface heating.

That is precisely the area where the person is. Furthermore, the heat loss indicator on warm floors is between 10 and 15%, which is two times less than the battery’s value.

The device works more efficiently because heating floors imply the presence of a "pie," which prevents heat from escaping through the floor in vain (no more than 5% is lost).

In addition, because the coolant is only heated to 40–45 °C, energy resources are used more sparingly (30–50% compared to radiators).

The complexity of the repair

Because the pipes in a private home are sealed off by a screed that needs to be taken apart, it can be challenging to identify the problem and perform repairs. This is a dusty and labor-intensive task.

Furthermore, once issues have been resolved, the heating elements must be poured with a concrete solution once more, and the freezing process must be allowed to finish. But one cannot help but notice how infrequently these breakdowns happen.

Heating speed

The water structure heats up gradually because the fluid inside the pipe warms up first, followed by the screed where they are located and finally the floor. However, they also gradually cool down.

It is important to remember, though, that a private home will warm up more quickly and effectively with a warm floor because they cover a larger space.

Microclimate

When selecting a heating system, consideration should be given to aspects that impact a person’s wellbeing in addition to the system’s capacity to heat the space:

1. Air humidity. Heating floors, as well as any heating system, dries the air. It is recommended to install an air humidifier, this will help improve the microclimate in the room. Although, it is worth noting that water floors are capable of maintaining water molecules at the required level, so they are preferable to install.
2. Drafts. Warm floors do not create drafts, unlike batteries, as it has a small conversion (30%). Another positive side of the absence of drafts – dust will spread less.
3. Ventilation. If the room is equipped with a supply fan, then the control of incoming air flows is required, and the warm floor will not cope with this task.

A combination with the interior

A harmonious interior is greatly influenced by the floor covering, as is the case with any construction project. In addition to making sure the warm water floor blends seamlessly with the room’s overall design, selecting a model that can be installed with a heating system is crucial when installing one in a private residence.

Ceramic tiles are the best choice; wood is not advised. Even though some models are combined with these devices, they have a unique marking on them.

Otherwise, because they are concealed by the finish coating, warm water floors have no effect on the room’s design.

Pros and cons of batteries

For many years, the primary source of heating for a variety of uses in a building has been the battery.

You should carefully consider all of their advantages and disadvantages before determining whether installing them in a private home is feasible.

Installation

One day’s worth of room heating can be more easily arranged in a private home by simply installing and connecting a radiator. The work’s central idea is:

• in laying pipes;
• installation of the radiator;
• Connection of the system of fittings.

Compared to heated floors, the installation itself will not be costly.

Economic operation

Since the warmest air is found beneath the ceiling when a private home uses a radiator to heat it, the majority of heat loss (up to 30%) happens through it.

As a result, the system functions less effectively and requires more money to maintain at its ideal temperature.

The complexity of the repair

Because the heating circuit is visible, fixing radiator heating is considerably simpler than fixing a warm floor. An exception would be if the pipes were walled up within the wall, but even in this scenario, the issue is simpler to fix.

Heating speed

All that’s needed to quickly heat the system when the radiator is connected to central heating is to turn the valve, allowing hot water to enter the pipes.

The procedure will take longer if the individual heating is located in a private residence because you will need to warm the coolant in the circuit first.

Additionally, the kind of radiator determines the heating speed. Cast iron batteries take the longest to warm up, followed by aluminum and bimetallic batteries.

Microclimate

The following elements affect how comfortable a person can be in the space:

1. Air humidity. Like floors with heating, radiators dry air, in this regard, it is better to install humidifiers.
2. Drafts. Batteries create strong air flows only over themselves, so they can smooth out small drafts coming from the window. With large cold air masses, they will not cope.
3. Ventilation. To control the air flow from the supply channel, the best output is to install the radiator. Hot air will be connected to it with cold, thereby creating comfortable conditions.

A combination with the interior

Batteries are not as attractive as warm floors because they are visible and cannot be obscured by a closet.

Nevertheless, more upscale, contemporary models are now available for purchase.

In the debate between a warm floor and traditional radiators for heating a private house, both options have their pros and cons. A warm floor offers uniform heat distribution, creating cozy warmth from the ground up, but it can be costly to install and may not provide instant heat. Radiators, on the other hand, offer quicker warmth and can be easier to control room by room, yet they can create uneven temperatures and take up wall space. The best choice depends on factors like budget, personal preference, and the layout of the house. Ultimately, it"s about finding the balance between efficiency, comfort, and practicality to keep your home warm and snug throughout the year.

Combined heating – floor + batteries

In a private home, combining two heating sources is feasible when:

• batteries are the main source of heat, and the warm floor is additional;
• Paul with heating – the main heating system, and radiators are an auxiliary.

If the cottage is two stories, the best way to heat it would be to build the heating floors on the ground floor and use batteries to heat the second floor.

By combining the two systems, you can take full advantage of their advantages and heat the house more cheaply.

The decision between a warm floor and conventional radiators for maintaining a comfortable and warm home can be difficult. Each choice has benefits and cons, and in the end, the choice you make will rely on your personal requirements and tastes.

Warm floors, like those made possible by radiant heating systems, have the advantage of uniformly dispersing heat from floor to ceiling, creating a pleasant and constant temperature. Because it can eliminate cold spots and use less energy because it operates at a lower temperature than traditional heating methods, this type of heating is particularly well-liked.

Radiators, on the other hand, have been a mainstay of residential heating for decades because they offer consistent warmth and the ability to customize the temperature in each room. In addition, radiators may be a more affordable choice up front, especially if you already have a central heating system.

For your own home, it’s important to weigh considerations like installation costs, energy efficiency, maintenance needs, and individual comfort preferences when choosing between radiators and a warm floor. Although warm floors can provide better comfort and long-term energy savings, they can be more expensive to install initially and may need to be maintained by professionals.

Radiators, on the other hand, offer a dependable and affordable heating option along with the bonus of zone control, which lets you independently regulate the temperature in various rooms of your house. Nevertheless, they can eat up valuable wall space and might not disperse heat as evenly as warm floors.

In conclusion, both warm floors and conventional radiators have advantages and can successfully maintain a warm and cozy atmosphere in your home throughout the winter. Making an informed decision that best meets your needs requires taking into account your preferences for heating, lifestyle, and budget.

Video on the topic

That the warm floor or radiators better ?

Warm floor or radiators?

Warm -floor radiators. Heating myths. Do you need a spare boiler?

🌕 Warm floor or heating radiators! Compare the cost of two systems