Comparison of boilers with open and closed combustion chamber

Selecting the ideal boiler for your house is essential for both safety and heating efficiency. The choice between a boiler with an open or closed combustion chamber is one of the most important distinctions to take into account. It is crucial to comprehend the distinctions between each type before making a choice because each has a unique set of benefits and factors to take into account.

Air from the surrounding room is drawn into an open combustion chamber boiler for combustion. This implies that for it to function effectively, there must be oxygen present in the space. In contrast, a sealed unit in a closed combustion chamber boiler draws air from the exterior of the house. Because there is less chance of combustion gases entering the living area, this setup is intended to be safer and more efficient.

The simplicity and lower initial cost of an open combustion chamber boiler are among its main advantages. Installing these boilers is typically less expensive than that of their closed combustion chamber counterparts. Because they have fewer parts, they may also be simpler to maintain and repair.

Open combustion chamber boilers do have certain disadvantages, though. They can be less effective because they take air from the room, particularly in well-insulated homes with restricted fresh air circulation. Additionally, there’s a greater chance of backdrafting, which could result in a buildup of carbon monoxide when combustion gases are drawn back into the home.

Closed combustion chamber boilers, on the other hand, have a number of benefits in terms of efficiency and safety. They lessen the possibility of dangerous gases entering the house by drawing air from the outside to ensure that the combustion process is isolated from the interior air. They are therefore a better choice for homes that are well-insulated and tightly sealed.

Additionally, because closed combustion chamber boilers precisely control the air intake, which leads to better combustion, they are generally more efficient. Over time, this can result in lower fuel consumption and energy costs, offsetting the higher installation-related upfront cost.

The decision between an open and closed combustion chamber boiler ultimately comes down to a number of variables, including your budget, your home’s layout, and your heating requirements. You can make an informed choice that protects your home’s comfort and safety by being aware of the distinctions between these two kinds of boilers.

Boilers with open combustion chamber and atmospheric burner

The most basic type of household boiler is an open combustion chamber model, which consists of just a burner and a heat exchanger above. These boilers are typically floor-standing rather than wall-mounted. In these models, the boiler body has holes that allow air to be drawn from the room for combustion. The combustion products are then released through a conventional vertical chimney. Another name for these is atmospheric.

Boilers featuring an open combustion chamber are less complicated to maintain, more dependable, and nearly silent due to the burner’s flame being the only source of noise. However, there are drawbacks to this design:

1. To ensure the proper amount of oxygen necessary for normal combustion of gas, the boiler requires good ventilation, sometimes even forced ventilation.
2. A traditional vertical chimney is required for the removal of combustion products, the quality of draught depends on the literacy of its design. In case of errors in design, back draft is also possible, when the flame is blown out in small or strong gusts of wind .
3. Atmospheric burners used in open-type combustion chambers are more prone to clogging and require more careful and frequent maintenance, although in general the boiler design is less demanding for maintenance (it is sufficient to clean and rinse the heat exchanger and clean the burner module).
4. Compared to even the simplest boilers with a closed combustion chamber, atmospherics are inferior in terms of characteristics: gas consumption, efficiency , environmental friendliness.

Installing gas with an open combustion chamber is preferable in reasonably large homes with a separate boiler room, a tight budget, and a well-established traditional chimney.

Gas boilers that are floor-standing The greatest models and the most comprehensive selection guidelines

The choice of an open or closed combustion chamber in a boiler can have a significant impact on both safety and efficiency when selecting one for your house. Air from the surrounding environment is drawn into boilers with open combustion chambers, which can negatively impact performance in poorly ventilated areas and give rise to questions about indoor air quality. Closed combustion chamber boilers, on the other hand, are sealed systems that draw air from the outside and release combustion gases through a flue. This eliminates air contact between the burner and the interior air, increasing efficiency and safety. In order to maximize heating efficiency while putting safety and indoor air quality first, homeowners must be aware of the distinctions between these two types of boilers.

Differences between boilers with closed combustion chamber and supercharged burner

These are more advanced and technologically advanced boilers, usually wall-mounted, that cost between 10% and 30% more than their exact equivalents in the atmosphere. A closed combustion chamber denotes a separate combustion zone into which a turbocharger fan (turbine) blows air. The automation decides the fan speed based on the quantity of fuel burned. The economy and efficiency of the boiler are impacted by this principle of operation, which enables the most complete combustion of the gas and less heat loss through the boiler structure.

The air used for gas combustion in an open chamber is drawn from the street, and the combustion products are also released into the street, which is the primary distinction between an open and closed chamber. It is accomplished with a coaxial (lateral, two-pipe) chimney, where air intake occurs in the space between the inner and outer pipes and smoke extraction occurs in the inner pipe. As a result, these boilers can be placed in any room that is appropriate, like the kitchen.

Nevertheless, a real drawback of this design is its reliance on energy, or power from the grid, for operation. During the heating season, gas boilers typically use 40 to 80 kW of electricity per month. In the event of a power outage, even brief ones, the boiler will cease to burn. A generator can assist in resolving the interruption issue.

Bottom line advantages and disadvantages

The decision is not as clear-cut when you consider every aspect of boilers with a closed combustion chamber. In contrast to more basic atmospheric boilers, they offer a number of benefits in addition to several drawbacks.

Numerous considerations must be made when deciding between boilers with closed or open combustion chambers. Each type has advantages and disadvantages that can have a big impact on how well they work and whether they’re a good fit for your house.

Installing and maintaining boilers with open combustion chambers is usually less expensive. They don’t need a separate air intake system because they use ambient air to fuel their combustion. For some homeowners, they may be a more affordable option due to their simplicity.

Open combustion chamber boilers do, however, come with certain disadvantages. They can be less effective and more prone to drafts, particularly in areas with inadequate ventilation. Moreover, because they take in air from the surroundings, they might not work well in houses with poor ventilation.

Boilers with closed combustion chambers, on the other hand, have a number of benefits. In general, they outperform their open combustion counterparts in terms of efficiency and safety. They can function more dependably in a range of situations and are less vulnerable to drafts thanks to their sealed combustion chamber.

Closed combustion chamber boilers are also frequently quieter and emit fewer emissions, making them a more environmentally friendly choice. Compared to boilers with open combustion chambers, they might be more expensive initially, but over time, their increased performance and efficiency can result in lower energy costs.

In conclusion, your unique needs and circumstances will determine whether you choose a boiler with an open or closed combustion chamber. If simplicity and affordability are your top priorities, an open combustion boiler can be the best option. However, if reliability, efficiency, and the impact on the environment are crucial factors, then making the long-term investment in a boiler with a closed combustion chamber may be the better option.

Video on the topic

NEW MODEL RANGE OF WALL-MOUNTED BOILERS "ARDERIA" WITH CLOSED COMBUSTION CHAMBER.

The answer to the question… Floor standing boilers with closed combustion chamber or forced smoke extraction

Gas heating boilers with closed combustion chamber

Question to the trainer "Is it possible to connect a boiler with a closed combustion chamber to a normal chimney"?